Home > Organization > History

2005

  • Dr. Patricia Clugston Memorial Award for Excellence in Teaching to honor Dr. Patricia Clugston a past recipient of the Award for Excellence in Teaching and who died prematurely.
  • 180 incoming PGY1s.

2004

  • 160 incoming PGY1s.
  • 2004 collective agreement renewed. Renewal agreement effective April 1, 2004 to March 31, 2006. Negotiations were exceedingly difficult due to government imposed no wage increases. None the less, PAR was able too obtain improved language for Residents who will be required to travel to distributed training sites as a result of the medical school expansion including Employer agreement that Residents are not required to travel to their new site post call of immediately at the conclusion of their rotation.
  • Dues are increased to allow PAR to better meet the needs of its expanding membership. PAR orientations have a pleasant side effect, which is that of a more informed membership prepared to ensure that the Employer upholds their collective agreement.
  • New space. On October 1st PAR moves into its new space at 2010-401 W. Georgia, Vancouver. An open house is held in February 2005.

2003

  • New Member Orientation. On June 24th PAR holds its first ever combined incoming Resident orientation with a 75% attendance.
  • 128 incoming PGY1s. An increase of 8 from the historical numbers of 120. This is directly tied to the planned expansion of the medical school.
  • New Dean of Medicine. Dr. Gavin Stuart is hired.

2002

  • Medical School Expansion - Funding received to expand the medical school. PAR makes it known that it must have input.
  • New Era cont. - On April 23rd The health authorities release their "redesign" plans. Cost pressures as identified by health authorities are, for the most part, similar. Notably negotiated wage increases, operating costs for new facilities and equipment, increased public expectations, technological change, aging population. Province-Wide Impact: $195 Million in administrative savings and efficiencies, $165 Million as a result of best practices, $57 Million in revenue generation, $150 Million as a result of service changes for a total of $567 Million in projected savings. 6,500 FTE reduction (out of 107,000 FTEs) during the next three years. 3 outright facility closures; Enderby, Kimberley, and New Denver. Building four, 165 new assisted living beds combined with 3,000 residential care beds decommissioned for a net gain of 1,165 beds. Bed closures. Virtually no references to the impact on residency training.
  • 1:4 Hospital Call - The 2001-2004 collective agreement is ratified. Highlights include 1:4 on-site call schedule, and wage increases of 5.55%, 5.55%, and 1.5% in 2001, 2002, and 2003 respectively.
  • 24 Hour Help Line - PAR-BC enters into a partnership agreement with the VCHA's Employee and Family Assistance Program to provide Residents and their families with a 24-hour access line.
  • Vary PAR's Certification - As a result of the restructuring in health services delivery the HEABC applies to the LRB to vary PAR's certifications (as have all the bargaining associations).
  • New PG Dean - A new postgraduate dean of residency training is hired. PAR is a member of the search committee.

2001

  • Accreditation - The residency training programs are surveyed by the RCPSC, and CFPC. In the 18 months prior to the accreditation surveys, representatives from PAR participate fully in each of the 54 internal reviews designed to primarily identify a program's weaknesses in order to allow that program time to correct any deficiencies prior to the review.
  • Health Care Reform- PAR makes verbal presentations and submits written submissions to the Standing Senate Committee on Social Affairs, Science and Technology (the "Kirby Commission"), the Select Standing Committee on Health (the provincial legislative committee on health), and a joint presentation to the Commission on the Future of Health Care in Canada (the "Romanow Commission"). The message remains consistent; Residents and their associations need to be involved and their input sought in any changes to the provision of health care and health services delivery. It is today's Residents as the established physicians of the future who will be expected to work within and support the new system.
  • New Era - In December the Liberal Government amalgamates the 52 regional health boards into five health authorities, and one Provincial Health Services Authority (PHSA) mandated to provide Province-wide services such as cancer care. The five health authorities are the Vancouver Coastal Health Authority (VCHA), the Fraser Health Authority (FHA), the Northern Health Authority (NHA), the Vancouver Island Health Authority (VIHA), and the Interior Health Authority (IHA).

    The structural changes known as the "New Era for Patient-Centred Health Care" (the "New Era") are intended to: (1) provide high quality patient-centred care; (2) improve health and wellness for British Columbia; and (3) create a sustainable, affordable public health care system.

    The health authorities were instructed to produce health services delivery plans adhering to provincial standards in the redesign plans. Furthermore, each health authority had to sign a performance agreement. Finally, the health authorities were given a three year budget cycle (2002-2005) which is frozen for the duration.

2000

  • Dues Reduced - PAR reduces its dues from 2% to 1.5% post-Point System win.
  • Residents Advocate Award - PAR introduces a Residents Advocate Award to be issued annually to honor individuals who have improved the well being of Residents, and/or promote the interests of Residents. The Award carries with it a $1,000 donation to the charity of the recipient's choice. Dr. Galt Wilson, from Prince George, is the Award's inaugural recipient.

1998

  • Getting Somewhere with Government - In February PAR is asked to participate on the government initiated Primary Care Advisory Committee and, Provincial Coordinating Committee on Remote and Rural Health Services. Both committees are charged with looking at the issue of primary care with respect to different ways of providing primary care and how to get physicians into remote and rural areas.

1996

  • Revised PAR Governance - A governance review identifies the Board composition (program based) and size (40+) as unworkable, and unwieldy. The report recommends significantly decreasing the number of director positions to 12 charged with representing all members. The review also encourages the establishment of a program representatives council to function as a direct link between the Board and PAR's members. It is anticipated the combined changes will lead to increased efficiency and effectiveness. The recommendations are subsequently approved in a 1997 membership referendum.
  • Residents are Students - In May, PAR applies to the Labour Relations Board (LRB) to vary its certifications to be consistent with the recommendations of the Dorsey Commission and subsequent Regulation establishing PAR as the bargaining association for Residents Province-wide.

    The Health Employers Association of B.C. (HEABC) which is the bargaining agent for the Hospitals responds by applying to the LRB in August of the same year seeking to have Residents declared students and PAR decertified. The HEABC contends that Residents are not integral to the Hospitals operations. Rather, Residents function much like student nurses whose absence would not be noticed. In the alternate, should the LRB find that Residents are employees, the HEABC submits that UBC is the appropriate employer of Residents. UBC opposes the HEABC's submission that it is the appropriate employer of Residents but takes no position on the student argument. PAR begins an extensive lobby campaign and hires a researcher to "prove" that Residents provide service to the Hospitals.

    In the Spring of 1997 PAR successfully lobbies the then Ministry of Health to become involved in an attempt to find a solution.

    On July 21, 1997, a case management meeting is held at the LRB during which the HEABC concedes that Residents are employees but continues to maintain that UBC is the appropriate employer. UBC is represented by counsel and disagrees that it is the employer of Residents. A full hearing is scheduled for January 1998. It is subsequently adjourned. In 2001 the HEABC advises the LRB that it is dropping its application.

  • PAR Logo Unveiled - In July, PAR adopts as its logo the Spirit Catcher designed by Mr. Bryson Young. According to Mr. Young the Spirit Catcher was a familiar implement in the traditional culture of the Northwest Coast used primarily as a tool in the hands of the Shaman or Healer. PAR-BC felt it appropriate to adopt the Spirit Catcher as its logo invoking the great shamanic tradition which most assuredly began the history of healing in B.C.
  • New Digs - In October PAR moves to its current location at 900-601 W. Broadway.
  • Strike Mandate - In November the HEABC rejects all of PAR's bargaining proposals that have an "employee" slant. PAR cancels further talks until it has met with its members. In June, 1997, PAR's members give it an overwhelming strike mandate. PAR serves notice on the HEABC and applies to the LRB for mediation. A mediated settlement is reached in October which the members subsequently ratify.

1995

  • PAR Establishes Mock - LMCCQEII - The annual mock-LMCCQEII is established by PAR-BC to assist its members in preparing for Part 2 of the LMCC. The mock exam is primarily funded by a grant from the Associate Dean of Residency Training and registration fees. PAR assumes the administrative costs and any miscellaneous charges.
  • Tuition Fees Averted - PAR successfully lobbies the Dean of Medicine not to implement tuition fees for Residents - rumored to be $2,200 per year.

1994

  • Name Change - PARI changes its name from the Professional Association of Residents and Internes of British Columbia to the Professional Association of Residents of British Columbia (PARI-B.C. --> PAR-BC) to reflect the elimination of the interneship.
  • Dorsey Commission - The Government of B.C. strikes a commission to inquire into collective bargaining structures in the health sector on the union side; the "Dorsey Commission". PAR-BC makes a verbal presentation and submits a written submission. Dorsey recommends amalgamation of the bargaining units. Its recommendations are accepted resulting in five associations of unions; Residents, Nurses, Paramedical Professionals, and General Workers in the Community, and Facilities, representing unionized health care workers Province-wide.
  • Yet More Billing Number Restrictions - On February 11th at the request of the BCMA, the Medical Services Commission implements the Interim Measures on physician supply; any new billing numbers issued receive only 50% of the relevant fee.

    In June, the BCMA Board of Directors approves a FFS system of differential fees for new entrants to practice; the "Point System". Under the Point System new entrants to practice are issued a geographically restricted billing number at 50%, 75% or 100% of billings dependent on whether or not the area of the province he/she wishes to practice is over-serviced or under-serviced. All areas of the Province are deemed overserviced for general practice meaning any new entrant to practice receives 50% of FFS. After having collected 100 points a physician receives an unrestricted billing number to practice anywhere in the province at 100%. In general, it takes 5 years to obtain 100 points. The only hurdle to implementation is the 1992 PAR amendment to The Medical and Health Care Services Act prohibiting differential fees based on years in practice.

    In July, PAR's amendment to The Medical and Health Care Services Act is repealed thus enabling the Point System.

  • See You in Court - On April 4th the Medical Services Commission implements the Point System. PAR serves notice of its intent to challenge the Point System and Interim Measures in Court. The BCMA intervenes in support of the Point System and Interim Measures. PAR receives financial and moral support from the practising physicians in the Province. However, the bulk of the costs are paid for by PAR's members in the form of a member dues increase to 2%.

    Dr. Don Young, PAR's then president, submits two articles to the BCMJ deriding the Point System. One of his articles is accepted for publication and the other distributed as a supplement with the same BCMJ issue in which his article runs.

    In December, 1996, the Hearing against the Point System and Interim Measures concludes and on July 30, 1997 Madame Justice Levine rules that the Interim Measures and Point System violate the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. She also rules that the Medical Services Commission does not have the authority to implement the Point System and Interim Measures. In other words, she rules in PAR's favor on both the administrative law arguments and the Charter arguments. The Point System and Interim Measures are struck down. PAR applies to the court for Costs.

    On August 28, 1997 The Attorney General of B.C. files a Notice to Appeal Madame Justice Levine's decision, and the BCMA seeks and is granted intervener status in support. Mr. Justice Hall dismisses the appeal in 1999.

  • Costs- PAR applies for costs. Arguments conclude in January, 1998. In April 1998, Madame Justice Levine rules that PAR is entitled to 65% of increased costs. The Attorney General promptly appeals the decision. PAR is eventually awarded increased costs in 2001. The funds are subsequently used to replenish its Right to Practice Fund.

1993

  • Elimination of the Interneship - On July 1st the interneship is eliminated and two pathways to licensure - RCPSC or CFPC - are implemented. The College of Physicians and Surgeons of B.C. partially as a result of lobby efforts by PARI-B.C. maintains a "third pathway" to licensure which is restricted to practise in B.C.
  • Establishment of LMCCQEII - To be taken at 18 months post-M.D, is put in place by the Medical Council of Canada.
  • Task Force on Physician Supply Created - A multipartite B.C. Task Force on Physician Supply is formed to recommend supply options to the Ministry of Health. PARI-B.C. has representation to the task force. An Interim Measures Committee is charged with making recommendations that will remain in place until a long term plan for the Province is developed.
  • Strike Mandate - PAR receives strike mandate. PARI is given a 88% strike mandate by its members. Based on this, negotiations for a renewal collective agreement are concluded.

1992

  • JUNE - Prohibition of Differential Fees Based on Years in Practice - PARI successfully lobbies the Provincial Government to amend The Medical and Health Care Services Act to prevent payment of differential fees to physicians based on years in practice.

1989-1991

  • Wage Increases - Salaries increase a further 22%.
  • Relationship with the Professional Employees Association Ends - PARI severs its relationship with the Professional Employees Association choosing to establish its own office and identify. The separation is amicable.
  • Seaton Commission - The Government of B.C. appoints a Royal Commission of Inquiry (the "Seaton Commission") to look at restructuring of health care delivery. PARI makes a verbal presentation and submits a written submission. The Seaton Commission makes sweeping recommendations - "Closer to Home" - that among others sees the creation of regional health boards and community health councils responsible for the delivery of health care in their respective regions.

1985

  • Final Certification - The last of the teaching Hospitals (Victoria General) is organized. PARI-B.C. now represents almost every Resident in B.C.

1984

  • More Billing Restrictions - The Provincial Government brings in Bill 41 a measure intended to limit newly licensed physicians access to practice by restricting billing numbers. Dr. P. Wilson supported by PARI-B.C. and the Canadian Association of Internes and Residents (CAIR), challenges the legislation in the courts. Chief Justice Lysyk deems Bill 41 constitutional. His decision is appealed by PARI-B.C. and CAIR and overturned by the B.C. Court of Appeal which rules that Bill 41 does in fact violate the Charter. The restrictions are lifted. An application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada is dismissed in 1988.

1975

  • A Trade Union - The Labour Relations Code is amended giving professionals the right to organize. In December of that year PARI applies to the Labour Relations Board (LRB) for certification. The application is challenged by the Hospitals which argue that Residents are students and therefore not entitled to a salary or negotiated working conditions.

    The LRB conducts a hearing with St. Paul's Hospital selected as the "test" site and in 1976 rules that Residents are employees of the Hospitals. The decision, known as the Weiler Decision, paves the way for PARI-B.C. to collectively represent Residents and Internes in the British Columbia. Residents' organizing efforts and Residents collectively and individually now have the protection of the Labour Relations Code. PARI's primary goal is to achieve equitable wages for its members.

1974

  • Strike - Continued refusal by the Hospitals to increases wages and provide dental benefits leads to the first ever B.C. Resident Physicians strike. Withdrawal of services commences at Royal Columbian Hospital and within seven days extends to all the teaching Hospitals. Residents are legislated back to work and an arbitrator appointed to settle the dispute.

1972-1973

  • Students and Stipends - Residents are paid a stipend because they are classified as students. Some but not all Residents are paid at the following rates:

    R2 - $7,980 annum
    R3 - $8,580 annum
    R4 - $9,900 annum
    R5 - $10,680 annum

    Due to budget cuts the hospitals administrators unilaterally reduced Resident salaries and pay Residents according to duties.

  • Salaries Fall Behind - Residents in British Columbia received no salary increase since 1971 and incomes fell significantly behind their counter-parts in other provinces, and nurses. Cost of living was rising at 6% per annum. Health and welfare benefits provided to other employees were denied to Residents or not applied uniformly and consistently.

    Residents recognize that other associations made gains from organizing into a cohesive bargaining unit and so PARI-B.C. begins actively organizing. At the helm are Dr. Ken Dubeta as President, Dr. W. Cyr, Vice-President, and Dr. Tom McMurtry Secretary-Treasurer. They too are threatened with sanctions and termination.

1969

  • Residents Unite - 20% of Residents "lost" their jobs in 1969. The BCMA discourages house staff participation in decisions that directly impact them. Hospital administrators and program directors make decisions unilaterally. Scut work is on the rise.

    The Society of Medical Residents and Internes of Vancouver formed the Professional Association of Residents and Internes (PARI-B.C.) as its bargaining arm. Its goals were to: (a) protect the interests of internes and residents in all matters, (b) improve teaching programs, (c) achieve adequate remuneration and working conditions.

  • Meek Founding President - Despite threats of termination and sanctions, the founding Residents persevere. Dr. R. Meek is the inaugural president.